Justin Isfeld, born September 25, 1980, is an actor best known for playing MILF guy #1 in American Pie and its sequels. He landed the role in 1999, the same year he graduated high school. Before that, he worked as a child actor in several TV shows and movies. His biggest role outside of American Pie was playing the main character, Joey, in the 1996 movie Sticks and Stones.